Summary
In an Indian Express op-ed, Niharika Yadav of the XKDR Forum argues that the RBI's draft Foreign Investment Rules, 2026 make useful operational changes but cannot fix the real problem. That problem is Section 6 of the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999, under which capital account transactions are prohibited unless the RBI or the government permits them.
She cites a fall in India's net FDI from $40 billion in FY2021 to effectively zero in FY2025. Drawing on the Tarapore, Percy Mistry, U.K. Sinha and FSLRC reports, she proposes three principles: restrictions only when temporary and justified, security screening at entry by an inter-agency body and national treatment after entry.
Supporters of the current framework point to the value of capital-flow controls in crises and the security logic of Press Note 3.
WHY IT MATTERS FOR UPSC & STATE PCS
As the RBI finalises its draft Foreign Investment Rules, 2026, an op-ed has argued that operational simplification will not revive net FDI unless the restrictive legal default in FEMA Section 6 is overhauled.
Standard News
A Law That Starts With No
The tension is about defaults. India wants foreign capital, but its main capital law, Section 6 of the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999, says capital account transactions are prohibited unless the RBI or the government permits them. Reformers say that default breeds suspicion and friction. Defenders say it gives the State the flexibility a developing economy needs in a crisis. Both are right about something.
The case for reversing the default The argument, made in an op-ed by Niharika Yadav of the XKDR Forum, is structural.
Because the law begins with prohibition, everything built on it, including the RBI's draft Foreign Investment Rules of July 2026, is a list of exceptions. The draft has real merits: shorter sections, an investee-centric structure, harmonised definitions.
But it remains a set of permissions layered on a legal default of restriction. That default shapes behaviour well beyond the banned and capped sectors. Even where foreign capital is fully allowed, the State dictates the instrument, the legal form of the recipient and the price.
Transfers of unlisted shares between residents and non-residents need certified valuations before the deal and the draft narrows this further. Expert committees, including Tarapore, Percy Mistry, U.K. Sinha and the FSLRC, have long recommended a different design.
The FSLRC's version is that restrictions should apply mainly at the point of entry, with national treatment for foreign investors afterwards. Other countries show it can work. The US screens for security through CFIUS. Indonesia, in 2021, moved to a Positive Investment List that opens sectors by default and restricts only for defence, security or small-business protection.
The case for keeping a cautious default The other side's best argument starts with the data.
India's net FDI did collapse, from a peak of about $44.4 billion in FY2021 to under $1 billion in FY2025. But gross inflows stayed above $50 billion. The fall in net FDI came mainly from foreign investors repatriating profits and Indian firms investing abroad.
That is a sign of maturing markets, not proof that FEMA is driving investors away. Capital controls also have respectable backing. The IMF's Institutional View accepts temporary capital flow management measures as tools against volatility, the kind of shocks seen in the 1997 Asian crisis and the 2013 taper tantrum.
And Press Note 3 has a clear security logic: it guards against opportunistic, state-backed takeovers from neighbouring countries. Its 2026 amendment, which opened an automatic route for non-controlling stakes up to 10 per cent and set 60-day timelines for priority sectors, shows the system can loosen when needed.
TAN's position TAN's position is that the default should be reversed, with targeted screening, but for the right reason.
The net-FDI collapse is weaker evidence than reformers claim, so it should not carry the argument. The stronger case is about the rule of law. A system that requires permission for everything invites discretion, delay and pre-transaction pricing controls that tax evasion rules could handle after the fact.
Reversing the default would keep the State's real tools: security screening at entry by an inter-agency body and explicit, temporary emergency powers for macro shocks. What it would remove is the routine assumption that foreign capital needs a reason to be allowed.
TAN would reconsider if evidence showed that open-by-default systems left comparable economies more exposed to capital flight in crises than India's has been.
Quick Facts
Key numbers & takeaways — revise these first
-
FEMA, 1999 replaced the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act and governs India's capital account.
-
Under Section 6 of FEMA, capital account transactions are prohibited unless specifically permitted by the RBI or the government.
-
The RBI released the draft Foreign Exchange Management (Foreign Investment) Rules, 2026 on 21 July 2026, with comments due by 31 August.
-
The draft rules adopt an investee-centric structure and replace "Foreign Owned or Controlled Company" with "Foreign Controlled Entity".
-
India's net FDI was about $44.4 billion at its FY2021 peak and fell to under $1 billion in FY2025, while gross inflows stayed above $50 billion.
-
Foreign investment is prohibited in real estate business and capped in sectors such as digital media, broadcasting, multi-brand retail and pensions.
-
Press Note 3 (2020), issued by DPIIT, requires government approval for investment from countries sharing a land border with India; it was amended in March 2026.
-
The Financial Sector Legislative Reforms Commission (2013) recommended capital controls mainly at entry, with national treatment afterwards.
-
The US screens foreign investment through the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS).
-
Indonesia adopted a Positive Investment List in 2021 under Presidential Regulation 10/2021.
Connect the dots for your UPSC preparation.
Standard news covers the event. Log in to read our comprehensive analysis and uncover the hidden constitutional, structural, and ethical dimensions of this topic:
The full case for the current default, including why the net-FDI collapse reflects repatriation and outward investment more than investor flight
How FSLRC's entry-screening model and CFIUS would work in an Indian inter-agency setting
Why Press Note 3's 2026 amendment shows both the flexibility of the current system and its reliance on case-by-case discretion
The specific evidence that would change TAN's position and a design that keeps emergency capital controls explicit and temporary
Included in this analysis
Join thousands of aspirants analyzing the news deeply.
Unlock Premium — Rs.699 AnnuallyDon't have an account? Sign up for free