Summary
Student unrest at the Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute (SRFTI) in Kolkata entered its 40th day on 7 November 2026. It began after clashes at a 27 September campus event organised by the Akhil Bharatiya Grahak Panchayat, an RSS-affiliated group.
On 5 November, the administration acted against two contractual faculty members and discontinued several resource persons, extended the suspension of academic activities until 11 December and closed the hostels and mess.
The Student Union called the steps retaliatory. Registrar Deepak Kumar said contractual faculty are governed by the terms of their engagement and that, with classes suspended because of disruption by a section of students, there was no academic reason to engage resource persons.
Six students had been rusticated on 15 October.
WHY IT MATTERS FOR UPSC & STATE PCS
SRFTI extended its campus closure to 11 December 2026, shut hostels and the mess and acted against contractual teaching staff as a student protest reached its 40th day. The steps have raised questions about proportionality and collective punishment in public educational institutions.
Standard News
The Students Who Did Not Protest Are Paying Too
Imagine you head a film institute that has not held a regular class since late September. A clash at a campus event on 27 September led to a sit-in, police on campus, six rustications and a long list of demands, including your resignation.
Some students say they want to study and cannot. The government ministry that funds you is watching. You have to restore order somehow. On 5 November, the Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute's administration extended the suspension of classes to 11 December, closed the hostels and mess, acted against two contractual faculty members and discontinued several resource persons.
The easy reading is that the administration was firm in a crisis. But the measures were not aimed only at those accused of wrongdoing.
The cost on each side The case for firmness is real.
A small group can hold an entire institute hostage and students who want to complete their courses are losing a term. Vice-Chancellor Santosh Ajmera, as reported by PTI, said academic standards and students' futures cannot be held hostage to the demands of a few.
If the administration simply gives in, it signals that disruption works. But consider who loses from a hostel closure. Not only the protest leaders. Every resident student, including those who never joined the sit-in, many from outside Kolkata, loses housing and meals at once.
Earlier, in October, the institute had reportedly asked students to vacate within 24 hours and urged parents to take their wards home. A measure that falls on everyone, regardless of conduct, is collective punishment. The action against teaching staff raises a second issue.
Registrar Deepak Kumar said contractual faculty are governed by their terms of engagement. He said that because a section of students started and continues the disruption and classes are suspended, there is no academic justification for engaging resource persons.
Yet it was the administration that suspended the classes. Using its own decision as the reason to remove teachers looks less like necessity and more like a penalty. The Student Union says the staff are being punished for standing with students.
Where the
line should be drawn The relevant test is proportionality: is the measure suited to a legitimate aim, is it the least restrictive option available and does its benefit outweigh the harm? Restoring order is a legitimate aim.
Closing all hostels, rather than acting against individuals found to have broken rules, fails the least-restrictive test. Removing contractual staff without a hearing also falls short of natural justice, even though they lack the protection Article 311 gives permanent civil servants.
So the right course is to separate the two. Students accused of violence should face individual proceedings with a hearing. Hostels and classes should reopen in phases for those not facing charges. Action against contractual faculty should be paused until they are heard.
An independent inquiry into the events of 27 September would address the protest's founding grievance. This choice has a cost. Reopening may bring renewed disruption and the administration may look weaker. For the exam, the lesson is that an institution's response to dissent is judged by whom it punishes, not just by whether order returns.
Quick Facts
Key numbers & takeaways — revise these first
-
SRFTI, established in 1995, is an autonomous institute funded by the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting.
-
Its Governing Council is chaired by Union Minister of State Suresh Gopi.
-
The unrest followed a campus event on 27 September 2026 organised by the Akhil Bharatiya Grahak Panchayat.
-
Six students were rusticated on 15 October 2026 over alleged vandalism of the Vice-Chancellor's office.
-
Academic activities have been suspended until 11 December 2026 and hostels and the mess have been closed.
-
The administration acted against two contractual faculty members and discontinued several resource persons.
-
Students demand the Vice-Chancellor's resignation, police withdrawal, revocation of the rustications and an independent inquiry.
-
The FTII Pune student strike of 2015 lasted 139 days.
-
Article 311(2) protects civil servants from dismissal without inquiry; contractual staff are not covered by it.
Connect the dots for your UPSC preparation.
Standard news covers the event. Log in to read our comprehensive analysis and uncover the hidden constitutional, structural, and ethical dimensions of this topic:
The proportionality test applied step by step to the hostel closure, the class suspension and the action against contractual staff.
Why citing classes the administration itself suspended as the reason to drop teachers raises a question of institutional integrity.
The FTII Pune strike of 2015 as a case study in what prolonged confrontation costs students and institutions.
A resolution that separates individual accountability from collective penalty and names what the administration must accept as the cost.
Included in this analysis
Join thousands of aspirants analyzing the news deeply.
Unlock Premium — Rs.699 AnnuallyDon't have an account? Sign up for free