Topic 5 of 20
GS Paper 2 Elections and Party Symbols The unverifiable organisational-majority test in the ECI's Trinamool Congress symbol dispute under Paragraph 15

Lakhs of Affidavits, No Way to Check Them: Why the ECI's Party-Split Test Needs Auditable Party Elections

Source Indian Express, The Print, Times of India

A truck leaves Kolkata loaded with notarised affidavits, bound for the Election Commission in New Delhi. Somewhere near the Haryana border, its owners say, armed men try to take it; the rival camp asks why a Kolkata-Delhi truck was in Haryana at all. Six such trucks later, the real question is not who stopped the paper, but whether anyone can ever check what is written on it.

Summary

After the Trinamool Congress split following its defeat in the 2026 West Bengal elections, the Election Commission froze the party's name and symbol on September 17 and asked both factions, Mamata Banerjee's and Ritabrata Banerjee's Democratic Trinamool Congress, to file affidavits proving their support.

The contest has turned into an affidavit war: the Mamata faction alleges state police are collecting dummy affidavits for the rival group and the Ritabrata faction alleges one of its affidavit trucks was targeted near the Haryana border.

Both sets of claims are unproven. Behind them lies a structural flaw: the organisational test laid down in Sadiq Ali cannot realistically be verified at this scale and the ECI has in recent cases fallen back on counting legislators, which rewards defection.

WHY IT MATTERS FOR UPSC & STATE PCS

The Trinamool Congress factions are filing lakhs of affidavits with the Election Commission in its dispute over the party name and symbol, amid allegations of police coercion and an attempt to seize an affidavit truck. The Supreme Court has asked the ECI to decide the case within three months.

Standard News

A Test That No One Can Check Paragraph 15 of the Election Symbols Order, 1968

gives the Election Commission a single task when a recognised party splits: decide which rival group is the party. The Order itself does not say how. The method comes from Sadiq Ali v. Election Commission of India (1971), where the Supreme Court approved three tests: the party's aims and objects, its constitution and which group commands a majority in both its legislative and organisational wings.

The Trinamool dispute shows the third test breaking down in practice.

The

Rule as Written, the Rule as Practised The text asks for an organisational majority. In practice, that means affidavits from office-bearers and members, notarised on stamp paper, submitted by the lakh. After freezing the Trinamool name and symbol on September 17, the ECI asked both factions, Mamata Banerjee's and Ritabrata Banerjee's Democratic Trinamool Congress, to file such affidavits.

What followed shows why the method no longer works. The Mamata faction's Dola Sen has alleged that police stations across the state were directed to collect affidavits for the rival group, more than 1,100 each from 607 stations and that stamp paper was being rationed.

The Ritabrata faction alleges that one of its trucks carrying affidavits to Delhi was targeted near the Haryana border and its leader has given two different accounts of what happened. Each side's claims are allegations and none has been tested.

The police declined to comment and the Chief Minister has offered a probe if a formal complaint is filed. Even if every affidavit were genuine, no commission can verify lakhs of signatures within a court-set deadline of three months.

In September, the ECI's own counsel acknowledged how impractical physical verification would be.

What Happens When a Test Cannot Be Checked

Recent cases show the result. In the Shiv Sena dispute, the Uddhav Thackeray faction claimed 23 lakh affidavits, yet the ECI decided on the legislative majority and recognised the Eknath Shinde group. The NCP case in 2024 followed the same route.

The legislative test is easy to count, but, as the Supreme Court observed in Subhash Desai (2023), the legislative wing is not the whole party. A test based on MLAs and MPs makes it easier to engineer a split through defections and the Trinamool split, where most of the party's Lok Sabha MPs moved to back the NDA, fits that pattern.

The Reform That Would Fix the Evidence

The answer is not better affidavit counting but better evidence. Paragraph 15 rests on the ECI's power of superintendence under Article 324, which already lets it demand transparency from parties. Recognised parties could be required to hold periodic, auditable internal elections, with membership rolls and results filed with the Commission.

A split could then be judged against a record that existed before the dispute began, not against paper produced for the occasion. For the exam, the insight is that the ECI's quasi-judicial role is only as good as the evidence the law lets it use.

Sadiq Ali gave the right tests; the problem is that one of them has become unverifiable and that quietly hands the decision to whoever controls the legislators.

Quick Facts

Key numbers & takeaways — revise these first

  • The ECI froze the name All India Trinamool Congress and its symbol on September 17, 2026.

  • Interim names and symbols: Mamata All India Trinamool Congress with the Football Player symbol and Democratic Trinamool Congress with the Envelope symbol.

  • Paragraph 15 of the Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order, 1968 empowers the ECI to decide which rival group is the recognised party.

  • Sadiq Ali v. Election Commission of India (1971) set out three tests: aims and objects, the party constitution and majority in the legislative and organisational wings.

  • The Supreme Court directed the ECI to decide the Trinamool dispute within three months.

  • The Mamata faction alleges each of West Bengal's 607 police stations was asked to collect more than 1,100 affidavits for the rival group.

  • In 2017 the AIADMK factions filed about 10 lakh affidavits; in the Shiv Sena dispute the Uddhav Thackeray faction claimed 23 lakh.

  • In the Shiv Sena (2023) and NCP (2024) disputes, the ECI ruled on the basis of legislative majority.

  • Suvendu Adhikari became West Bengal's first BJP Chief Minister on May 9, 2026.

Beyond The Headlines
GS Paper 2 The unverifiable organisational-majority test in the ECI's Trinamool Congress symbol dispute under Paragraph 15

Connect the dots for your UPSC preparation.

Standard news covers the event. Log in to read our comprehensive analysis and uncover the hidden constitutional, structural, and ethical dimensions of this topic:

1

Why Sadiq Ali's organisational test collapses at the scale of lakhs of affidavits and how the ECI's own counsel conceded the verification problem

2

How the Shiv Sena and NCP rulings shifted the decisive weight to legislative majority and what Subhash Desai (2023) said about that shift

3

How the Tenth Schedule's merger rule and the symbol dispute interact when most of a party's MPs change sides

4

A reform blueprint built on Article 324: auditable internal elections, filed membership rolls and a pre-dispute evidence record

Included in this analysis

Deep Analysis Sharpens your Mains-level understanding.
8 Languages Read the news comfortably in your language.
PYQ Connection Direct connection with previous year Mains questions.
Expected Questions Possible upcoming questions for Prelims & Mains.
Daily Evaluation Daily Prelims test, plus category-wise Mains evaluation.
Mentor Observation Daily, topic-wise expert feedback on your tests.
Value Additions Important Case Studies and daily Vocab Word.

Join thousands of aspirants analyzing the news deeply.

Unlock Premium — Rs.699 Annually
FOUNDATION MEMBER PRICE
₹6,999 ₹699 Annually

From Year 2: only ₹399/month for Foundation Members

More from 11 Nov 2026

Short titles by category — open any story to read it fully.