Summary
In an Indian Express essay, Vineet Nayar, founder-chairman of the Sampark Foundation and former CEO of HCL Technologies, argues that as AI moves into classrooms and workplaces, education can no longer reward only correct answers.
What will matter is the ability to question, challenge, experiment and imagine. He traces how a curious child taught in a language she barely understands falls silent and comes to believe she is not smart and argues that instruction in the mother tongue is what gives children the confidence to ask why.
The essay connects a classroom problem to a much older truth: societies advance through those who doubt, not only those who know.
WHY IN NEWS FOR UPSC & STATE PCS
The Indian Express published the essay on October 6, 2026, amid ongoing debates over the three-language formula and the entry of AI tools into government school classrooms. The author argues that while the country debates how many languages children should learn, it should pay more attention to the language in which they begin learning, since that is where the confidence to question is built or lost.
Standard News
When Answers Become Cheap, Who Will Ask the Questions?
For generations, Indian classrooms have crowned one kind of child: the one with the right answer, delivered first. AI has quietly ended that contest. A machine can now produce a correct answer in seconds, for anyone. The question this raises is not whether children should still learn facts, but what becomes valuable when answers cost nothing.
The silent girl in the classroom Vineet Nayar, who has worked for nearly two decades in government schools, describes a six-year-old who chatters, argues and questions everything at home.
At school the teacher explains in a language she barely understands. Other hands go up. Hers does not - day after day. Her slide happens in three steps:
- She does not understand the language.
- So she does not understand the lesson.
- So she concludes she is not as smart as the others.
Doubt has always been the engine The classroom is only the newest place where this truth plays out.
Every serious knowledge tradition has advanced through the person who questioned:
- India's own early thought holds doubt in high regard. A famous Rigvedic hymn on creation ends not in certainty but in the admission that even the highest witness may not know. Gargi pressed Yajnavalkya with question after question in open debate.
- Galileo turned a telescope to the sky and questioned an accepted picture of the heavens. Einstein questioned what everyone assumed about time itself. None of them was rewarded for memorising the accepted answer. They mattered because they asked what others had stopped asking.
What
AI really changes Put the two together and a clear conclusion appears. Answers were always cheaper than they looked; progress always came from questions. AI simply makes that visible to everyone at once. In an age of instant answers, the scarce goods are:
- Comprehension
- understanding the answer well enough to see where it might be wrong.
- The courage to ask
- noticing the problem nobody has framed and testing an idea when the outcome is uncertain. Both begin in the same place: a first classroom where a child understands what is being said and believes she has something worth saying. A nation that wants citizens who can question AI must first make sure its six-year-olds can question their teacher - in a language they truly understand.
Quick Facts
Key numbers & takeaways — revise these first
-
The essay is by Vineet Nayar, founder-chairman of the Sampark Foundation and former CEO of HCL Technologies.
-
The author has worked for nearly two decades with children and teachers in government schools.
-
The National Education Policy 2020 recommends the mother tongue, home language or local language as the medium of instruction at least until Grade 5.
-
The Annual Status of Education Report measures foundational literacy and numeracy among rural children in India.
-
The author calls the ability to question the fourth language, beyond those taught in school.
-
He argues that learning English is different from being required to learn everything through English.
-
UPSC set the essay topic The doubter is a true man of science in 2024.
-
UPSC set the essay topic Destiny of a nation is shaped in its classrooms in 2017.
Connect the dots for your UPSC preparation.
Standard news covers the event. Log in to read our comprehensive analysis and uncover the hidden constitutional, structural, and ethical dimensions of this topic:
The full classroom domain, including why the slide from not understanding the language to believing one is not smart is so hard to reverse.
A second domain drawn from Indian and Western knowledge traditions, from the Nasadiya Sukta and the Kalama Sutta to Galileo and Einstein, showing doubt as the engine of knowledge.
The synthesis that emerges only from comparing both: why AI turns comprehension and courage into the scarce goods of the century.
Ready-to-use examples and structure for the 2024 essay topic The doubter is a true man of science.
Included in this analysis
Join thousands of aspirants analyzing the news deeply.
Unlock Premium — Rs.699 AnnuallyDon't have an account? Sign up for free